Forsythe Jewelers

Forsythe Jewelers Forsythe Jewelers has been quietly selling the finest jewelry in the greater Rochester area since 1927.

Three generations of the Forsythe family have been trusted for diamonds, colored gemstones, repairs, and custom designs.

Jewelry sitting in a drawer deserves more than dust.Our new Jewelry Box Consultation is here for anyone who's inherited ...
06/20/2026

Jewelry sitting in a drawer deserves more than dust.

Our new Jewelry Box Consultation is here for anyone who's inherited a collection, accumulated pieces over the years, or simply wants a trusted second opinion on what they own.

Bring in your jewelry and we'll sit down with you to identify what you have and talk through each piece, so that we can explore your options together.

The first 30 minutes are always on us, but if we purchase or redesign something during your visit, the entire consultation is complimentary!

06/18/2026

Your jewelry deserves hands that know it by heart.

Certified gemologists, lifelong craftspeople, and a team that treats every piece like it matters. Because to us, it does.

66 Monroe. Ave | Pittsford, NY
Monday – Saturday: 10am – 5pm

The woman. The legend. The reason we all smile a little more at work.Susie turns 70 today, and her birthstone? Pearls, n...
06/16/2026

The woman. The legend. The reason we all smile a little more at work.

Susie turns 70 today, and her birthstone? Pearls, naturally. Timeless, warm, and adored by everyone in the room. Coincidence? We think not.

Stop in to wish Susie a happy birthday! Oh, and if you've been eyeing a certain set of pearls, today feels like the perfect excuse to come try them on.

"Recently, I have been thinking a lot about Sam and Ruthie Hall, the original owners of our building. As Flag Day was fa...
06/14/2026

"Recently, I have been thinking a lot about Sam and Ruthie Hall, the original owners of our building. As Flag Day was fast approaching, I felt compelled to get a flag back up on the porch. I properly "retired" our weathered flag that once hung and secured a new one. My parents, Barb and Dick, and Sam and Ruth are smiling down on us today."

Happy Flag Day from Susie and the Forsythe team!

06/13/2026

K came in knowing exactly what she needed: a ring she could wear every day, through every task, without compromise.

With a hands-on job and a love of jewelry, she worked with Ashley to design something that fit her life as beautifully as it fits her finger.

The result? A smooth, domed pave band, low-profile by design and polished to feel as effortless as it looks.

(Ashley loved it so much she wants to make one for herself and call it "the K". We think that says it all.)

Need a little inspiration? Nicole has you covered. 🐝Here is the latest Forsythe Staff Pick: perfect for summer, this cha...
06/11/2026

Need a little inspiration? Nicole has you covered. 🐝

Here is the latest Forsythe Staff Pick: perfect for summer, this charming bee pin from our estate case features round diamonds and emeralds.

One emerald carries a small chip from its past life, but that's part of the character.

Stop in and see what all the buzz is about before this one flies away.

He knew she wanted a yellow gold split shank, but wasn’t entirely sure on the center. The entire team was thrilled when ...
06/09/2026

He knew she wanted a yellow gold split shank, but wasn’t entirely sure on the center. The entire team was thrilled when he landed on an asscher cut.

Have you ever heard of this faceting style?

06/04/2026

Nearly 100 years in the making. Welcome to Forsythe.

66 Monroe. Ave | Pittsford, NY
Monday – Saturday: 10am – 5pm

The pearl is the only gem created entirely by a living creature, a quiet miracle of nature that has symbolized purity an...
06/02/2026

The pearl is the only gem created entirely by a living creature, a quiet miracle of nature that has symbolized purity and elegance across nearly every culture on Earth.

Ancient Greeks believed pearls were tears of joy shed by Aphrodite as she rose from the sea. In China, they were thought to protect the wearer from fire and dragons. And in the 1910s, Pierre Cartier traded a double strand of natural pearls for a Manhattan mansion.

If June is your month, stop in and see our selection. Your pearls are waiting, and hey, a New York City mansion has to start somewhere 😉

Happy Birthday to our Sales Floor Manager, Ashley! 🎂Ashley has been part of the Forsythe family for years, and her genui...
05/30/2026

Happy Birthday to our Sales Floor Manager, Ashley! 🎂

Ashley has been part of the Forsythe family for years, and her genuine care for every customer who walks through our door and every piece that walks out of it is unmatched. There is no one quite like her, and we would not be the same without her.

Wishing you the most wonderful birthday, Ashley. We love you endlessly! 🤍

Address

66 Monroe Avenue
Pittsford, NY
14534

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 5pm
Tuesday 10am - 5pm
Wednesday 10am - 5pm
Thursday 10am - 5pm
Friday 10am - 5pm
Saturday 10am - 5pm

Telephone

+15855865954

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Forsythe Jewelers posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Forsythe Jewelers:

Shortcuts

Share

Category